Floyd fans can be pretty hard on this tune, and Rogers works as a whole. I'll agree there is less melody, and musically speaking it's an easy argument to side with the nay's. Yet, the hard edge created by the guitar work and percussion sets up Rogers narrative singing style. This, combined with lyrical content , makes for a style of music that is unique and of quality. Did anyone see him perform Wish U Where Here with Clapton during one of the Tsunami FR's?